• Sun. Nov 22nd, 2026

A Disciplined Budget, but Is the Economy Freer?

ByETimes

Nov 22, 2026

By Tinotenda Bhunu

HARARE – ZIMBABWE’S 2027 National Budget arrives at a time when the Government is keen to consolidate macroeconomic stability and demonstrate that the country is moving towards a more predictable economic environment. The figures appear to support that ambition. Treasury projects economic growth of 3.5%, revenue collections of ZiG349.5 billion and expenditure of ZiG358.3 billion. The resulting fiscal deficit is estimated at ZiG8.8 billion, equivalent to 0.5% of GDP.

These projections present a picture of fiscal restraint. Yet a national budget should not be judged simply by the size of its deficit, the amount of revenue collected or the number of projects announced. The more important question is whether the policies behind those figures address the constraints that prevent households, farmers and businesses from creating wealth.

CABS Foreign Currency Savings Account

Zimbabwe’s economic challenge is not only one of stabilising prices or managing public finances. It is also about rebuilding confidence in institutions, securing property rights, reducing the cost of doing business and creating conditions in which productive investment can take place.

The 2027 Budget contains proposals that could advance these objectives. It also retains some of the contradictions that have characterised Zimbabwe’s economic policy: a desire to formalise economic activity while taxing financial transactions, an ambition to promote domestic production while relying heavily on border revenue, and a commitment to infrastructure development within a public expenditure structure dominated by recurrent obligations.

The real test is whether the Government is prepared to move beyond managing economic instability and tackle the institutional and policy problems that keep the economy from growing.

Growth projections reveal the limits of the recovery

Treasury projects real GDP growth of 3.5% in 2027, down from the 5% growth projected for 2026. The slowdown is partly attributed to the anticipated effects of the El Niño-induced drought.

The agricultural sector remains particularly exposed to weather conditions. A poor rainfall season affects more than crop output. It can reduce rural incomes, weaken demand for goods and services, increase food prices and place additional pressure on public resources. Its effects can also extend to manufacturing, transport and trade through reduced agricultural supply and higher input costs.

The drought risk is real, but it should not obscure the structural weaknesses that make the economy vulnerable to climatic shocks in the first place. Zimbabwe’s agricultural performance still depends heavily on rainfall, while irrigation infrastructure, water storage, reliable electricity and efficient agricultural markets remain inadequate.

This is why resilience cannot be measured only by the size of an emergency allocation. It should be measured by the country’s ability to maintain production when rainfall is poor.

The Government’s projected growth path also raises a broader question. What will drive growth beyond favourable weather conditions and commodity prices? Sustainable growth requires investment, productivity improvements, secure property rights, competitive markets and a regulatory environment that allows businesses to respond to changing demand.

A 3.5% growth rate may represent continued expansion, but it is not sufficient on its own to transform the employment prospects and living standards of a population that needs a much larger productive economy.

A small deficit does not automatically mean a healthy fiscal position

The projected deficit of ZiG8.8 billion, or 0.5% of GDP, is one of the budget’s strongest headline figures. It suggests that Treasury intends to keep expenditure broadly within the limits of available resources and prudent borrowing.

The budget also proposes reducing the Reserve Bank’s permitted financing of the fiscal deficit from 20% to 5% of the previous year’s fiscal revenue. This is an important institutional signal. Excessive central bank financing of government expenditure can undermine monetary discipline and weaken confidence in the currency.

However, fiscal discipline must be assessed through more than the deficit. The composition and quality of public expenditure matter just as much.

The Government projects total expenditure of ZiG358.3 billion, comprising ZiG284.7 billion in recurrent expenditure and ZiG73.6 billion in capital expenditure. Capital spending is expected to increase from 2.3% of GDP in 2026 to 3.8% in 2027.

That is a welcome shift towards investment. But recurrent expenditure still accounts for approximately four-fifths of the total budget envelope.

Compensation of employees alone is projected at ZiG167.3 billion, representing 46.7% of total expenditure. Public servants are essential to the delivery of education, healthcare, security and other services. The issue is not whether government employees should be paid. They should. The question is whether the public service is adequately structured and resourced to deliver measurable improvements in service quality and productivity.

A large wage bill is not automatically wasteful, just as a large capital budget is not automatically productive. What matters is the value citizens receive from public spending.

Treasury must therefore demonstrate that the additional resources allocated to capital projects will translate into completed infrastructure, functioning facilities and lower costs for businesses and households.

The proposed fiscal restraint will mean little if government continues to accumulate arrears, delay payments to suppliers or finance projects that do not deliver adequate economic returns.

The revenue system is still heavily dependent on taxation

The Government expects to collect ZiG349.5 billion in 2027. Of this, ZiG335.6 billion is projected to come from taxes, while non-tax revenue is estimated at ZiG13.9 billion.

This means that approximately 96% of projected revenue will come from taxation.

The dependence is not surprising, but it raises a fundamental question about the relationship between taxation and economic growth. Is the Government expanding the tax base because more businesses are becoming productive and more people are entering formal employment, or is it relying on existing taxpayers to carry an increasingly large share of public financing?

The 2026 revenue outturn offers some insight. Between January and September, total collections reached ZiG224.7 billion, exceeding the target of ZiG198.7 billion. VAT generated ZiG62.4 billion, or 27.8% of total revenue. Personal income tax contributed ZiG37.1 billion, while corporate income tax generated ZiG29.1 billion.

VAT’s contribution is particularly significant. It is a tax on consumption, and its economic burden can ultimately be reflected in the prices paid by consumers. This deserves attention in an economy where households already face pressure from the cost of living.

Personal income tax collections, meanwhile, underperformed their target by 5.4%. Treasury attributes this to weaker-than-projected growth in the taxable payroll base. That explanation points to a deeper problem: a limited formal employment base constrains the Government’s ability to collect revenue from personal incomes.

The proposed increase in the tax-free threshold from US$100 to US$150 is welcome relief. But the long-term answer lies in expanding formal employment and making it easier for businesses to grow.

The Government cannot sustainably broaden the tax base without broadening the productive economy.

IMTT reduction: welcome relief, but the underlying problem remains

The proposed reduction in the Intermediated Money Transfer Tax is one of the more important measures in the budget.

Treasury proposes reducing the rate on ZiG transactions from 1.5% to 1.25%, and on foreign currency transactions from 2% to 1.75%. It estimates that the changes will result in revenue forgone of approximately US$100 million.

The Government argues that lower transaction costs will encourage the use of formal payment platforms, improve transaction traceability, support formalisation and strengthen tax compliance.

There is economic logic to this argument. When formal financial transactions are expensive, businesses and individuals have an incentive to rely on cash or informal channels. Reducing the cost of formal payments could increase the volume of transactions passing through the financial system.

But the policy also exposes a contradiction. Government wants to encourage electronic payments and formal financial intermediation while continuing to tax the movement of money through those same channels.

IMTT is imposed on transactions rather than on the profitability of the underlying economic activity. Money may move several times through a supply chain before a final product reaches the consumer. Each taxable movement can add to the cost of doing business.

The proposed reduction is therefore a step in the right direction, but it does not resolve the underlying problem. Treasury should publish the evidence used to assess the reform, including transaction volumes, the proportion of payments made electronically, currency composition and the additional revenue generated through improved compliance.

If lower rates generate more formal activity and a broader tax base, the Government should demonstrate this with data. The longer-term objective should be a tax system that does not penalise the financial activity it wants to encourage.

Customs policy must support production, not simply protect revenue

The budget’s customs proposals reveal an interesting shift in thinking.

During the first nine months of 2026, customs duty collections exceeded their target by 13.2%. Treasury attributed the performance partly to increased imports.

Higher customs receipts may strengthen the fiscus in the short term, but they do not necessarily indicate stronger domestic productive capacity. An economy can collect more revenue from imports while remaining dependent on imported finished goods.

There is nothing inherently wrong with importing. Businesses need access to machinery, technology and intermediate inputs that may not be available competitively at home. The concern is when domestic producers cannot compete because of high production costs, unreliable infrastructure and policy uncertainty.

The proposal to reduce customs duty on cellular phones from 25% to zero is therefore worth noting. Treasury expects the measure to encourage formal imports, improve the competitiveness of compliant retailers and expand VAT collections through declared transactions.

The proposed reduction in customs duty on electric vehicles from 25% to 10% also signals an effort to lower the cost of adopting new technology.

These measures reflect a useful principle: lower barriers can sometimes increase formal economic activity and improve revenue collection through other tax channels.

However, the same principle must guide the treatment of local producers. Protection should not become a permanent substitute for competitiveness. Businesses should be encouraged to invest in technology, improve productivity and meet consumer demand, rather than depend indefinitely on tariffs and restrictions.

The objective should be to make domestic production competitive, not merely to make imported products expensive.

Public expenditure must reduce the cost of doing business

The increase in capital expenditure is one of the budget’s most important commitments. Capital spending is projected to rise to 3.8% of GDP in 2027, up from 2.3% in 2026.

The infrastructure programme places significant emphasis on transport, water and sanitation, energy, health, education and information and communication technology.

This is important because infrastructure is not simply a development statistic. It affects the cost of production, the movement of goods, access to markets and the willingness of businesses to invest.

A farmer who cannot move produce to market because of poor roads loses income. A manufacturer facing unreliable electricity must absorb additional costs through backup power. A business operating without reliable water supply may have to invest in its own infrastructure. These costs eventually affect prices, wages and investment decisions.

The budget’s infrastructure allocations should therefore be assessed against their economic returns, not just the amount of money assigned to each sector.

For transport, the relevant questions include whether roads are maintained, whether logistics costs are falling and whether infrastructure connects productive areas to domestic and regional markets. For energy, the test is whether businesses experience more reliable and affordable electricity. For water, it is whether irrigation and urban water systems become more dependable.

Government should publish project-level information showing planned costs, implementation timelines, procurement arrangements and measurable outcomes. Without that transparency, a higher capital allocation risks becoming another expenditure commitment rather than an improvement in productive capacity.

The challenge is not simply to spend more on infrastructure. It is to ensure that every investment removes a real constraint on economic activity.

Agriculture needs productivity, not just seasonal support

Agriculture remains central to Zimbabwe’s economic stability, yet its performance is constrained by inadequate irrigation, limited infrastructure, uncertain market arrangements and climate exposure.

The budget allocates resources to agricultural extension and business advisory services and proposes investment in irrigation and other support programmes.

These interventions are necessary. But agricultural policy should be judged by improvements in productivity, not merely by the number of farmers receiving inputs or the amount of equipment purchased.

The important indicators are crop yields per hectare, irrigation utilisation, post-harvest losses, access to finance and the ability of farmers to sell produce at competitive prices.

There is also a property rights dimension. Farmers need secure and predictable rights over the land they use. The budget’s recognition of land tenure security and digitisation of land administration is therefore significant.

Digitising records, improving surveys and strengthening valuation systems can make land administration more transparent. But technology cannot substitute for enforceable rights, predictable legal processes and effective dispute resolution.

A digital record is useful only if the underlying rights are clear and respected.

Where land rights are insecure or difficult to transfer, farmers and investors may be reluctant to make long-term improvements. Financial institutions may also be less willing to accept land-related interests as security.

Title deeds and secure tenure should therefore be treated as part of a wider institutional reform programme, rather than as an administrative exercise. The objective should be to give legitimate rights-holders greater certainty, improve investment incentives and make land administration more accessible.

Mining reform must go beyond beneficiation

Mining remains a major source of exports, foreign currency and fiscal revenue. The budget recognises the sector’s importance through allocations to the Ministry of Mines and Mining Development, exploration initiatives and the development of a mining cadastre information management system.

The proposed mining cadastre is particularly important. A transparent and reliable system of mineral rights administration can help reduce overlapping claims, improve access to information and strengthen confidence in the allocation of mining rights.

But beneficiation cannot be achieved through policy declarations alone.

Investors need predictable licensing procedures, secure mineral rights, reliable infrastructure and a stable fiscal framework. Local processing also requires electricity, technology, skilled labour and access to finance.

The Government should therefore avoid treating beneficiation as an instruction to businesses. It should focus on removing the constraints that make local processing commercially unviable.

The mining sector must also be governed transparently. The public should be able to understand how mineral rights are allocated, how royalties are assessed and whether the country is receiving an appropriate return from its natural resources.

A country rich in minerals should not be satisfied with recording extraction. It must build institutions that encourage investment while ensuring that the benefits of resource extraction are accounted for and transparently managed.

Debt resolution is necessary, but financing choices matter

The budget identifies external arrears to international financial institutions as a major obstacle to Zimbabwe’s access to development finance. The outstanding amounts to the World Bank Group, African Development Bank and European Investment Bank are substantial.

The Government’s intention to advance the arrears clearance and debt resolution process is important. Restoring normal relations with international financial institutions could improve access to concessional financing and support infrastructure and development programmes.

However, the process must be approached carefully. The possibility of using commercial financing where concessional resources are insufficient deserves particular scrutiny.

Commercial borrowing can provide access to capital, but it generally carries different costs and risks from concessional finance. If borrowed funds are directed towards projects that do not generate adequate economic and social returns, the country could exchange one debt problem for another.

The 2027 Budget also projects domestic borrowing of approximately ZiG21.5 billion and debt service payments of ZiG31.2 billion. These figures should be read carefully: debt service includes principal repayments and interest, while new borrowing may finance maturing obligations as well as other fiscal needs. They are not directly comparable to the projected fiscal deficit.

The central question is whether borrowing will finance productive assets and strengthen the economy’s capacity to repay, or simply defer fiscal pressures.

Debt resolution should ultimately be accompanied by transparent borrowing, credible public investment appraisal and stronger parliamentary oversight of public finances.

Special Economic Zones and the risk of incentives without reform

The proposed Provincial Special Economic Zones are intended to stimulate industrial activity, attract new investment and support regional development.

The budget proposes preferential corporate income tax rates, accelerated capital allowances, customs duty exemptions and expedited VAT refunds for qualifying new investments.

It also proposes safeguards to prevent existing businesses from artificially restructuring or relocating merely to access tax concessions.

These safeguards are necessary. Tax incentives can become costly if they reward investment that would have happened anyway or allow businesses to shift profits without creating additional productive capacity.

The more important issue, however, is whether the zones will offer a genuinely better business environment.

Investors need reliable electricity, serviced industrial land, transport links, predictable regulation and access to skilled labour. They also need confidence that policy will not change abruptly after capital has been committed.

A special economic zone cannot succeed simply because it offers a lower tax rate. It must offer conditions that make production more competitive.

The proposed incentives should therefore be assessed against additional investment, jobs created, exports generated and local value added. Government should publish periodic evaluations showing whether the revenue forgone is justified by measurable economic benefits.

Regional development is a legitimate objective, but it should not become an expensive competition between provinces to offer tax concessions.

Stability must be supported by accountable institutions

One of the more important questions in any budget is not only how money is raised and spent, but who is responsible for ensuring that public resources are used as intended.

The budget allocates ZiG855 million to the Office of the Auditor-General. It also points towards strengthening monitoring and accountability mechanisms.

These commitments matter because public finance is ultimately a matter of public trust. Citizens and businesses are expected to comply with tax laws and contribute to government revenue. In return, they should be able to scrutinise how that revenue is used.

Auditing should not end with the identification of irregular expenditure. There must be follow-through: responsible officials should account for findings, recommendations should be implemented and repeat weaknesses should attract consequences.

The same principle applies to public procurement and infrastructure projects. Citizens should be able to access information on project costs, contractors, implementation progress and delays.

Fiscal discipline is not simply a matter of Treasury controlling expenditure. It also requires institutions capable of preventing waste, detecting abuse and holding decision-makers accountable.

The unfinished business of economic reform

The 2027 Budget contains several proposals worth supporting: a lower IMTT rate, a higher personal income tax-free threshold, reduced customs duties on selected goods, increased capital expenditure, land administration reforms and efforts to strengthen the mining cadastre.

But these measures should not be mistaken for a complete programme of economic transformation.

Zimbabwe’s development challenge is fundamentally institutional. Businesses need confidence that contracts will be respected, property rights protected, regulations applied predictably and public resources managed transparently. Farmers need secure tenure and access to markets. Investors need assurance that the rules governing their investments will not be changed arbitrarily.

The Government’s ambition to broaden the tax base will be difficult to achieve if formal businesses continue to face high compliance costs and uncertainty. Its industrialisation agenda will struggle if firms cannot access reliable power, affordable finance and secure property rights. Its agricultural resilience programme will remain incomplete if farmers lack the confidence and incentives to invest in long-term improvements.

There is a further issue of policy consistency. A budget may announce reforms, but businesses make investment decisions based on the credibility of those commitments over time. Predictability is itself an economic asset.

The Government should therefore publish clear implementation targets for the major reforms in the budget, report progress regularly and explain openly when targets are missed. Parliament and citizens should be able to assess not only how much has been spent, but what has been achieved.

The 2027 Budget should be judged by whether it makes productive activity easier, strengthens the security of property and contracts, improves public services and reduces the cost of doing business.

Zimbabwe does not lack policy announcements. It has a long record of ambitious development plans. What it needs is a more consistent institutional environment in which people can make decisions, invest, trade and build without constantly having to price in policy uncertainty.

Macroeconomic stability is necessary, but it is not the destination. The ultimate measure of success will be whether stability creates room for enterprise, investment and rising living standards.

A budget that collects more revenue but leaves production constrained will eventually reach its limits. A budget that strengthens the institutions and freedoms on which production depends can expand the economy from which future revenue is collected. That is the unfinished business of Zimbabwe’s economic reform.

Tinotenda Bhunu is an economist by profession. LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/tinotenda-bhunu-114645208?utm_source=share&utm_campaign=share_via&utm_content=profile&utm_medium=android_app


Discover more from Etimes

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

0 0 votes
Article Rating

Leave a Reply

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Discover more from Etimes

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x